Matthew Summers vs James Story Head-to-Head Stats, Results & Performance Comparison

• Matthew Summers edges out James Story slightly in recent second serve performance, winning 45.29% of points compared to Story's 45.04%. Does this give Summers a slight advantage on serve? Yes, but the margin is minimal.
• James Story has a superior return game in recent form, capturing 44.56% of opponents' second serve points versus Summers' 43.04%. Will Story’s return proficiency be crucial? It could play a significant role.
• When returning first serves, Matthew Summers holds an edge, winning 29.32% of points compared to Story’s 26.04%.
• James Story is slightly better at saving breakpoints, with a success rate of 55.87% compared to Summers' 54.65%. Could this pressure performance decide tight sets? It certainly provides an edge.
• Their overall win rates over the past year are almost identical, with Summers achieving 62.12% and Story 62.16%, indicating a tightly matched contest.
• Both players have their best win percentages on Hard courts (62%), but Summers is notably weaker on Clay, while Story struggles more on Grass.
• James Story has faced opponents with a lower average ranking (421.64) compared to Summers (354.2), suggesting Summers has been challenged by tougher competitors.
• In deciding sets, Summers has been more successful, winning 62% compared to Story's 56%, which could be pivotal if the match goes the distance.

Editorial Prediction (October 22, 2025, UTC):

As we analyze the stats, it's evident that Matthew Summers and James Story are closely matched players. Their head-to-head numbers show both have distinct strengths and minimal differences in overall performance.

Summers brings a moderate edge in second serve success and first serve return stats. However, James Story's slightly stronger breakpoint saving skills and second serve return proficiency could give him an edge in crucial moments.

The quality of opponents faced by Summers over the past year indicates he has been tested more against higher-ranking players, possibly better preparing him for challenging matches.

Despite all metrics being close, the deciding set performance favors Summers, suggesting he maintains composure under pressure. Taking all these factors into account, Matthew Summers is slightly more likely to prevail in this upcoming clash.