Brooke Black vs Alicia Smith Head-to-Head Stats, Results & Performance Comparison

• In recent form, Alicia Smith has won 41.79% of points on her second serve, slightly below Brooke Black, who achieved 42.06%.
• When it comes to returning second serves, Alicia Smith outperforms Brooke with a win rate of 48.09% compared to Brooke's 45.97%.
• For first serve returns, Brooke Black has an edge, securing 34.56% of points, whereas Alicia Smith has won 32.44%.
• Under pressure, Alicia has saved 47.73% of breakpoints, which is marginally better than Brooke's 46.21%. Could this statistic suggest who handles high-stress moments better?
• Over the past year, Brooke Black has a higher match win ratio at 56.00% versus Alicia Smith's 43.33%. What does this say about consistency?
• Both players excel on hard surfaces, each with a win rate of 46%, highlighting no particular surface advantage.
• Although both have played at the Challengers/ITF tournaments > $10K level, Brooke has a clearer advantage with a win rate of 58.33% compared to Alicia’s 40.00%.
• Alicia Smith has faced opponents with a higher average rank of 326.8, suggesting exposure to tougher competition than Brooke, whose opponent average rank is 358.64.
• When matches go to deciding sets, Brooke Black has a stronger history of success, winning 64% compared to Alicia Smith’s 60%.

Editorial Prediction (October 7, 2025, UTC):

The upcoming match showcases two players with distinct strengths and past performance patterns. Brooke Black demonstrates a slight edge in second serve performance and excels at returning first serves more effectively than Alicia Smith.

Alicia has faced tougher competition in the past year and has slightly better breakpoint-saving stats. However, Brooke's superior overall match win percentage and success in deciding sets provide her with a persuasive advantage.

Despite both players showing proficiency on hard surfaces, Brooke’s consistency and ability to handle decisive moments make her the more likely victor in this matchup.

Based on the available statistics and recent form, Brooke Black is favored to win this contest.