Access all the details around bookmaking market for the St. Louis Cardinals vs Cincinnati Reds contest for the MLB 2025 on the September 17, 2025, in our analysis here. We uncover the St. Louis Cardinals vs Cincinnati Reds predictions, best bets and odds markets for this fixture in the our report beneath.
Who The Odds Predict: to triumph
- Evaluating the odds for points scored indicates a likelihood of a 79.11% prediction of this match having over 5.5 total points scored:
Match Over 5.5 Points → 1.26Prediction Chance Of O/U (incl. EI) (5.5) Over 79.11 % Under 26.32 % Above is implied from odds. Login now to reveal our expert predictions.
- Evaluating the odds for total points suggests there is a 40.82% prediction of this game having over 9.5 total points scored:
Match Over 9.5 Points → 2.45Prediction Chance Of O/U (incl. EI) (9.5) Over 40.82 % Under 62.7 % Above is implied from odds. Login now to reveal our expert predictions.
- Derived via the sportsbook odds, Cincinnati Reds are the favorite to cover the -1.5 handicap with extra innings included in this fixture, with a 70.92% probability of doing so. A solid prediction? Most likely, because Oddsmakers are skilfull analysts:
St. Louis Cardinals -1.5 Handicap → 2.98
Cincinnati Reds -1.5 Handicap → 1.41Prediction Chance Of Handicap (incl. EI) (-1.5) St. Louis Cardinals 33.56 % Cincinnati Reds 70.92 % Above is calculated from odds. Login now to find out our expert picks.
- Analyzing the odds for points scored suggests a likelihood of a 100% expectation of this game having higher than 4.5 total points:
Match Over 4.5 Points → 1.00Prediction Chance Of O/U (incl. EI) (4.5) Over 100 % Under 100 % Above is implied from odds. Login now to reveal our expert predictions.
- Implied from the bookies odds, Draw are the pick to win after the first inning in this match with a 57.14% chance of leading. Is this accurate? We think so, due to Sportsbooks are skilfull analysts:
St. Louis Cardinals First Inning → 3.92
Cincinnati Reds First Inning → 4.10
Draw First Inning → 1.75Prediction Chance Of 1st Inning Result St. Louis Cardinals 25.51 % Cincinnati Reds 24.39 % Draw 57.14 % Above is implied from odds. Login now to find out our expert picks.
To explore value bets in order make money, check out our expert Baseball betting picks at Matchstat.com. Uncover today’s best Baseball value bets here.
H2H-Based Prediction: St. Louis Cardinals to triumph
| Team | Head-To-Head Match Wins |
|---|---|
| St. Louis Cardinals | 6 |
| Cincinnati Reds | 4 |
Head-2-Head: St. Louis Cardinals (6 – 4) Cincinnati Reds.
St. Louis Cardinals to win. Why? For the most recent 10 H2H fixtures between them, St. Louis Cardinals are up 6 – 4. Our H2H analysis goes back to the game between them in 2003. This suggests that St. Louis Cardinals are likely to win in this upcoming battle. Their most recent game took place on the Tue, 16 Sept 25, when St. Louis Cardinals achieved a 3 – 0 victory.
Will Cincinnati Reds reverse the trend and overcome the H2H stats? The last game Cincinnati Reds came out on top vs St. Louis Cardinals was on Mon, 15 Sept 25, indicating that they can still turn things around.
Form-Based Prediction: Cincinnati Reds to prevail
Analyzing team momentum before this game, St. Louis Cardinals claimed a win versus Cincinnati Reds with a result of 3-0. Cincinnati Reds lost against St. Louis Cardinals with a score of 0-3. St. Louis Cardinals have triumphed in 4 of their last 10 matches versus all opponents, while Cincinnati Reds prevailed in 5 of their recent 10 matches against all teams, suggesting maybe Cincinnati Reds have an edge approaching this match.
St. Louis Cardinals vs Cincinnati Reds Top Betting Odds For The Match
Winner (incl. extra innings)
Over Under (incl. extra innings)
Handicap (incl. extra innings) && -1.5
First Inning Result
St. Louis Cardinals vs Cincinnati Reds Tips
Over Under (incl. extra innings) 4.5 → Over stands out as a worthwhile bet → 1.00
