MLB Preview And Prediction: Cincinnati Reds vs New York Mets Betting Tips & Picks September 7, 2025

Prediction Indicated By Odds: to win

• Assessing the odds for points scored suggests a likelihood of a 80% prediction of this game having more than 5.5 total points scored:
  Match Over 5.5 Points → 1.25

  Prediction	Chance Of O/U (incl. EI) (5.5)
  Over	80 %
  Under	25.45 %
  Above is implied from odds. Login now to get our expert picks.

• Analyzing the odds for total points indicates a likelihood of a 42.55% prediction of this game having more than 9.5 total points:
  Match Over 9.5 Points → 2.35

  Prediction	Chance Of O/U (incl. EI) (9.5)
  Over	42.55 %
  Under	60.02 %
  Above is implied from odds. Login now to get our expert predictions.

• Calculated from the sportsbook odds, New York Mets are the pick to beat the -1.5 handicap with extra innings included in this fixture, with a 66.58% probability of doing so. A good prediction? Yes, because Bookmakers produce sharp predictions:
  Cincinnati Reds -1.5 Handicap → 2.73
  New York Mets -1.5 Handicap → 1.50

  Prediction	Chance Of Handicap (incl. EI) (-1.5)
  Cincinnati Reds	36.63 %
  New York Mets	66.58 %
  Above is implied from odds. Login now to get our expert predictions.

• Analyzing the odds for total points implies a likelihood of a 100% expectation of this game having over 4.5 total points:
  Match Over 4.5 Points → 1.00

  Prediction	Chance Of O/U (incl. EI) (4.5)
  Over	100 %
  Under	100 %
  Above is calculated from odds. Login now to find out our expert predictions.

• Calculated from the sportsbook odds, Draw are the pick to win after the first inning in this fixture with a 58.14% chance of leading. A reliable forecast? We think so, as Bookies do their analysis:
  Cincinnati Reds First Inning → 3.95
  New York Mets First Inning → 4.28
  Draw First Inning → 1.72

  Prediction	Chance Of 1st Inning Result
  Cincinnati Reds	25.32 %
  New York Mets	23.36 %
  Draw	58.14 %
  Above is calculated from odds. Login now to discover our expert predictions.

For deeper insights so you can win big, check out our in-depth Baseball betting picks on our platform. Unlock today’s winning Baseball value bets here.

Prediction Based On Head-to-Head: Too close to call

Head-to-Head: Cincinnati Reds (5 – 5) New York Mets.
It’s a tight contest! Can either team break the deadlock? For the most recent 10 direct matches between these teams, both teams share an equal record. Our H2H analysis goes back to the fixture between them in 2003. This indicates that the scheduled fixture is up for grabs. Their most recent meeting was on the Sat, 06 Sept 25, where Cincinnati Reds achieved a 6 – 3 victory.

Will this be the tiebreaker? Both Cincinnati Reds and New York Mets have an equal H2H record. This upcoming match will determine the stronger side.

Form-Based Prediction: New York Mets to win

Considering team momentum before this game, Cincinnati Reds triumphed versus New York Mets with a result of 6-3. New York Mets suffered a defeat versus Cincinnati Reds with a result of 3-6. Cincinnati Reds have triumphed in 3 of their recent 10 games vs all teams, whereas New York Mets got the victory in 5 of their last 10 games against all teams, indicating maybe New York Mets are in the better form heading into this match.

Comparing team trends provide interesting insight into momentum in order to uncover successful wagers

Versus All Teams Streaks:

• Cincinnati Reds: 3 Losses.

Cincinnati Reds vs New York Mets Top Sportsbook Odds For The Match

Winner (incl. extra innings)

1W

1.862

2W

2.05

Over Under (incl. extra innings)

> 5.5

1.25

< 5.5

3.93

> 9.5

2.35

< 9.5

1.666

> 4.5

1

< 4.5

1

Handicap (incl. extra innings) && -1.5

1W -1.5

2.73

2W -1.5

1.502

First Inning Result

1W

3.95

2W

4.28

X

1.72

Cincinnati Reds vs New York Mets Tips

Over Under (incl. extra innings) 9.5 → Under stands out as a rewarding gamble → 1.67