James Madison Dukes vs Marshall Thundering Herd: Prediction, Head-to-Head, Odds & Stats (Sat, 18 Oct '25)

As the NCAA gears up for a thrilling matchup on Saturday, October 18, 2025, at its local time kickoff, we are drawn to a tantalizing face-off between the James Madison Dukes and the Marshall Thundering Herd. So, how have these two teams fared in their past encounters? In the latest trio of head-to-head clashes, both teams have claimed victory once, with one game ending in a stalemate. The most recent bout saw the Thundering Herd edge out the Dukes 1-0 on November 14, 2024, a result achieved under familiar home conditions.

Looking at the trajectory leading up to this showdown, James Madison Dukes enter with a relatively subdued performance, having recently drawn 1-1 against the Georgia State Panthers. In stark contrast, the Marshall Thundering Herd cruised through their last match with an impressive 4-1 thrashing of the Kentucky Wildcats. Such momentum disparity inevitably raises the question of how pivotal these performances might be in determining the outcome of this upcoming match.

Individual brilliance can certainly swing a game, so who stands out on each side? S. Djeha for the Dukes, netting 3 goals so far, is certainly one to watch. K. Francis, leading with 3 assists, shines brightly for the Thundering Herd. The top ratings tell a compelling tale: Joshua Moya tops the Dukes with a 7.9 rating, while Yasha Schaerer leads the Herd's strong performers with a commendable 7.58. In assessing team control and chance creation, Marshall's substantial 63.6% average possession overshadows the Dukes' 42.2%, a factor that could be pivotal given each team's corner averages—Marshall leads here too with 6.67 corners to the Dukes’ 2.

Discipline can tip competitive balance, and here, James Madison holds a slight advantage with fewer yellow cards at 11, compared to Marshall’s 19, although both teams have shown fair play by avoiding red cards thus far. Considering all these statistics, momentum, and individual player performances will be integral to the final outcome and it's likely the Marshall Thundering Herd, with their current form and critical advantage in possession, may have the edge to secure victory in this tightly contested face-off.