MLB Preview And Prediction: New York Yankees vs Detroit Tigers Betting Tips & Picks September 11, 2025

Who The Odds Favor: to triumph

• Evaluating the odds for total points indicates there is a 79.18% expectation of this game having over 5.5 total points:
  Match Over 5.5 Points → 1.26

  Prediction	Chance Of O/U (incl. EI) (5.5)
  Over	79.18 %
  Under	25.71 %
  Above is implied from odds. Login now to find out our expert picks.

• Assessing the odds for total points suggests a likelihood of a 40.49% prediction of this match having over 9.5 total points scored:
  Match Over 9.5 Points → 2.47

  Prediction	Chance Of O/U (incl. EI) (9.5)
  Over	40.49 %
  Under	62.58 %
  Above is implied from odds. Login now to reveal our expert picks.

• Derived via the bookies odds, Detroit Tigers are the pick to cover the -1.5 handicap with extra innings included in this fixture, with a 59.21% chance of doing so. An accurate tip? Yes, as Bookies produce sharp predictions:
  New York Yankees -1.5 Handicap → 2.31
  Detroit Tigers -1.5 Handicap → 1.69

  Prediction	Chance Of Handicap (incl. EI) (-1.5)
  New York Yankees	43.29 %
  Detroit Tigers	59.21 %
  Above is implied from odds. Login now to reveal our expert predictions.

• Evaluating the odds for points scored implies a likelihood of a 100% prediction of this match having more than 4.5 total points:
  Match Over 4.5 Points → 1.00

  Prediction	Chance Of O/U (incl. EI) (4.5)
  Over	100 %
  Under	100 %
  Above is calculated from odds. Login now to find out our expert predictions.

• Implied via the bookies odds, Draw are the pick to be ahead after the first inning in this fixture with a 55.25% probability of leading. A good prediction? We think so, because Bookies do their analysis:
  New York Yankees First Inning → 3.54
  Detroit Tigers First Inning → 4.60
  Draw First Inning → 1.81

  Prediction	Chance Of 1st Inning Result
  New York Yankees	28.25 %
  Detroit Tigers	21.74 %
  Draw	55.25 %
  Above is calculated from odds. Login now to find out our expert picks.

For deeper insights so you can win big, read our in-depth Baseball predictions on our platform. Uncover today’s winning Baseball edge bets here.

Prediction Based On H2H: Detroit Tigers to secure victory

Head-2-Head: Detroit Tigers (6 – 4) New York Yankees.
Detroit Tigers to win. The reason? Over the last 10 H2H encounters between them, Detroit Tigers are up 6 – 4. Our head-to-head analysis starts from the game they had in 2003. This indicates that Detroit Tigers are likely to prevail in this scheduled game. The last match between them took place on the Wed, 10 Sept 25, when Detroit Tigers achieved a 11 – 1 victory.

Will New York Yankees reverse the trend and overcome the H2H stats? The most recent match New York Yankees got the better of Detroit Tigers was on Wed, 09 Apr 25, proving that they are not without hope.

Prediction Based On Recent Form: Nip and tuck

Examining team momentum heading into this match, New York Yankees faced a loss vs Detroit Tigers with a score of 1-11. Detroit Tigers triumphed vs New York Yankees with a score of 11-1. New York Yankees have prevailed in 5 of their last 10 games vs all teams, whereas Detroit Tigers won 5 of their last 10 matches against all teams, indicating maybe this match is too close to call.

New York Yankees vs Detroit Tigers Top Bookie Odds For The Match

Winner (incl. extra innings)

1W

1.641

2W

2.43

Over Under (incl. extra innings)

> 5.5

1.263

< 5.5

3.89

> 9.5

2.47

< 9.5

1.598

> 4.5

1

< 4.5

1

Handicap (incl. extra innings) && -1.5

1W -1.5

2.31

2W -1.5

1.689

First Inning Result

1W

3.54

2W

4.6

X

1.81

New York Yankees vs Detroit Tigers Tips

Winner (incl. extra innings) → New York Yankees appears a gainful stake → 1.64